Showing posts with label My Own Private Idaho. Show all posts
Showing posts with label My Own Private Idaho. Show all posts

Sunday, July 3, 2011

Day 16: My Own Private Idaho (1991)


It's been 16 days and I haven't taken into consideration just how exhausting this experiment would be. Luckily, I have a Gus Van Sant film to review today. It could be worse.

Starring: Keanu Reeves, River Phoenix, Udo Kier
Directed by: Gus Van Sant

A modern recreation of Shakespeare's 'Henry IV' told with gay, street-smart hustlers.

The Positives:

- Gus Van Sant is an excellent director, and his use of breaking the proscenium arch recalls theatrical plays and delivers both amusement and exposition.
- The gritty tone of the movie is nicely contrasted without the colorful title screen and setting markers.
- Huzzahs all around. Keanu Reeves is actually showing some emotion!
- River Phoenix also shines as Mike, whose narcolepsy is used both tragically and comedically, something I feel perfectly juxtaposes the entire film.
- A 'Simpsons' cameo! (The first 'Treehouse of Horror' episode too.)
- The long, wide shots of various scenery has kind of become a staple of Independent cinema, and while I'm sure this fin wasn't the first to feature it, it's put to good use here.
- Twangy covers of a more classical score occupies the background flawlessly when needed.
- Showing a key sex scene via only still frames actually seemed more romantic than if the actual movement were shown.
- The old street bum in a thriller jacket made me laugh. Hard.


The Negatives:

- Sometimes the acting is a bit much, especially in scenes that have roots in 'Henry IV'.
- The Shakespearean dialogue is toned down at times, and that's when I think the performances really shine. It also makes the scenes where the dialogue is heavily Shakespearean stand out for the worst.
- I felt much more invested in the characters than the journey they were on.

Grade: C+

While the uneven tones of 'Henry IV' plague the film at times, the performances of Phoenix and Reeves more than make up for it. Van Sants wonderful direction only helps.